Task Based learning as a synergy between Explicit and Implicit Learning
Task Based learning as a synergy between explicit and implicit learning
After a quick review of characteristics and traits of explicit and implicit learning we’ll use it as an overlay to discuss TBLT and traditional language learning.( If you’re already familiar feel free to skip this part.)
Although Left-Right brain theory has long been disproven it
is sufficiently accurate as a heuristic and closely correlates with the Explicit
Implicit learning model; left brain explicit, right brain implicit. It might
even be the most recent iteration of the L-R brain hypothesis.
Here's a quick comparison of explicit and implicit learning
|
Differences Between Implicit and Explicit Learning |
||
|
|
Explicit Learning |
Implicit Learning |
|
Nature of learning |
Conscious, deliberate |
Unconscious, subconscious, liminal, automatic, incidental |
|
Awareness of learning |
Learners are aware and actively engaged |
Learners are often unaware yet actively engaged |
|
Processes |
analytical, summative, cumulative, correlation and coordination |
Synergy, synthesis, Intuitive, emergent, dynamic, insight, Holistic, |
|
Instruction |
Requires direct instruction and deliberate practice. |
Does not require direct instruction; occurs through exposure. |
|
Examples |
Test prep, input, memorize facts |
L1, acquisition, skill learning, adaptation, play, active inference |
|
Memory |
declarative memory, short term, visual structural memory, |
procedural memory, working memory, perceptual and muscle memory, active inference, LTM |
|
|
|
|
Viewing them as a dynamic spectrum rather than as a dichotomy helps reveal their symbiosis.
Because professional training and certificate programs are test-driven by conformity to standards they are naturally closer to the explicit mode. Math deals with formal systems abstractions, hence, more explicit. Feasible limits to hands on learning of experimental science place it in closer to the explicit mode. Musical instruments, sports, and other motor skills start out as exploratory but quickly drift to the explicit mode as we leverage theory to accelerate learning. This learning swings through explore~ exploit cycles as new constructs are worked into a performance repertoire students naturally rise up through the flow channel. This is adaptive learning. Adaptive Learning processes are going to be closer to the center or to the implicit side of the spectrum.
And this brings us to our topic.
L1 acquisition is organic. The infant’s learning strategies and L1 co-adapt with his/her increasingly complex interactions with an increasingly complex environment by employing a full range of cognitive functions.
Implicit learning allows individuals to acquire knowledge and skills without conscious attention to the learning process. It relies on intuitive and subconscious processes and often happens through exposure rather than direct instruction.
On the other hand, explicit learning is a conscious and deliberate process where learners are aware and actively engaged. This type of learning involves analytical and conscious processes, requiring direct instruction and deliberate practice. Examples include studying for tests, learning musical instruments, and academic education in subjects like mathematics and science. Implicit learning is more associated with procedural memory, while explicit learning relies on declarative memory.
Applications of implicit learning include native language acquisition, social skills development, and motor skills, whereas explicit learning is applied in formal education, professional training, and learning new languages through formal instruction.
|
Differences and Distinctions Between TBLT and Traditional Language Teaching Methods |
||
|
Aspect |
Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT) |
Traditional Language Teaching Methods |
|
Learning Focus |
Meaningful communication and task completion |
Mastery of language forms and structures |
|
Learning Approach |
Implicit, with some explicit instruction as needed |
Explicit, with some implicit elements in communicative approaches |
|
Role of the Teacher |
Facilitator and guide, providing support and feedback |
Instructor and authority, providing direct instruction |
|
Student Role |
Actively engaging, language use and acquisition are guided by tasks and problem-solving |
Passive recipient, practicing language through drills and exercise |
|
Instructional Techniques |
Task completion, real-world activities, collaborative learning, |
Grammar-translation, drills, repetition, explicit explanations, memorization |
|
Feedback |
Integrated within tasks, often implicit, continuous |
Direct correction, explicit feedback, quizzes and tests |
|
Focus on Grammar |
Emergent from task performance, context, habituated through synchrony with cognition and experience, |
Central focus, taught explicitly and systematically, rote |
|
Use of Authentic Materials |
High, tasks often mirror real-life language use |
Variable, often simplified and controlled language |
|
Assessment Methods |
Performance-based, assessing ability to complete tasks |
Form-based, assessing knowledge of language rules |
Discussion of Applications
Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT):
Applications: TBLT is particularly effective in environments where language use mirrors real-life contexts, such as in business language training, immersion programs, and advanced language courses. It is suitable for learners who benefit from experiential learning and need to develop practical language skills.
Advantages: Encourages natural language use, intrinsic motivation, and fosters the development of communicative competence, individual differences. It aligns well with contemporary pedagogical trends emphasizing learner-centered instruction and real-world applicability.
Challenges: Requires careful task design to ensure language learning objectives are met. Teachers need to be adept at providing appropriate feedback and integrating explicit instruction as necessary. Assessment can be complex due to the focus on performance rather than discrete language elements.
Traditional Language Teaching Methods:
Applications: These methods are often used in formal educational settings, such as schools and universities, where systematic knowledge of language rules is valued, test prep, corrective, and review. They are suitable for those beginners who need a strong foundation in grammar and vocabulary.
Advantages: Provides clear structure and systematic progression of language knowledge. Easier to measure progress through standardized tests and assessments. Can be efficient for learning specific language forms and rules.
Challenges: May not fully engage learners or develop communicative
competence. Can be less motivating for learners due to the repetitive and
mechanical nature of drills. Often criticized for not preparing learners
adequately for real-life language use.If the goal is simply testing of formal language explicit learning will be dominant. If communication and meta-learning are the goals implicit learning might be the dominant using explicit learning for remediation.
Conclusion: Implicit and Explicit learning modes complement each other, two feet in a series of steps, each providing stability for the other, implicit learning explores, explicit learning exploits. TBLT and traditional learning can feed this symbiosis, explicit learning bottom up, implicit learning top down, yin and yang in a strong emergence.
Ellis, R. (2003). Task-based Language Learning and Teaching . Oxford University Press.
Long, M. H. (2015). Second Language Acquisition and Task-Based Language Teaching . Wiley-Blackwell.
Richards, J. C., & Rodgers, T. S. (2001). Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching . Cambridge University Press.
Skehan, P. (1998). A Cognitive Approach to Language Learning . Oxford University Press.
|
Differences and Distinctions Between TBLT and Traditional Language Teaching Methods |
||
|
Aspect |
Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT) |
Traditional Language Teaching Methods |
|
Learning Focus |
Meaningful communication and task completion |
Mastery of language forms and structures |
|
Learning Approach |
Implicit, with some explicit instruction as needed |
Explicit, with some implicit elements in communicative approaches |
|
Role of the Teacher |
Facilitator and guide, providing support and feedback |
Instructor and authority, providing direct instruction |
|
Student Role |
Actively engaging, language use and acquisition are guided by tasks and problem-solving |
Passive recipient, practicing language through drills and exercise |
|
Instructional Techniques |
Task completion, real-world activities, collaborative learning, |
Grammar-translation, drills, repetition, explicit explanations, memorization |
|
Feedback |
Integrated within tasks, often implicit, continuous |
Direct correction, explicit feedback, quizzes and tests |
|
Focus on Grammar |
Emergent from task performance, context, habituated through synchrony with cognition and experience, |
Central focus, taught explicitly and systematically, rote |
|
Use of Authentic Materials |
High, tasks often mirror real-life language use |
Variable, often simplified and controlled language |
|
Assessment Methods |
Performance-based, assessing ability to complete tasks |
Form-based, assessing knowledge of language rules |
Discussion of Applications
Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT):
Applications: TBLT is particularly effective in environments where language use mirrors real-life contexts, such as in business language training, immersion programs, and advanced language courses. It is suitable for learners who benefit from experiential learning and need to develop practical language skills.
Advantages: Encourages natural language use, intrinsic motivation, and fosters the development of communicative competence, individual differences. It aligns well with contemporary pedagogical trends emphasizing learner-centered instruction and real-world applicability.
Challenges: Requires careful task design to ensure language learning objectives are met. Teachers need to be adept at providing appropriate feedback and integrating explicit instruction as necessary. Assessment can be complex due to the focus on performance rather than discrete language elements.
Traditional Language Teaching Methods:
Applications: These methods are often used in formal educational settings, such as schools and universities, where systematic knowledge of language rules is valued, test prep, corrective, and review. They are suitable for those beginners who need a strong foundation in grammar and vocabulary.
Advantages: Provides clear structure and systematic progression of language knowledge. Easier to measure progress through standardized tests and assessments. Can be efficient for learning specific language forms and rules.
Challenges: May not fully engage learners or develop communicative competence. Can be less motivating for learners due to the repetitive and mechanical nature of drills. Often criticized for not preparing learners adequately for real-life language use.
Ellis, R. (2003). Task-based Language Learning and Teaching . Oxford University Press.
Long, M. H. (2015). Second Language Acquisition and Task-Based Language Teaching . Wiley-Blackwell.
Richards, J. C., & Rodgers, T. S. (2001). Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching . Cambridge University Press.
Skehan, P. (1998). A Cognitive Approach to Language Learning . Oxford University Press.
Comments
Post a Comment