Task Design and Selection

 

 

 

 

Task Design and Selection

People have asked me for a simple step by step method for designing TBL tasks. Here’s the short reply, the long reply follows. We’ll assume the needs assessment has already been done as part of curriculum design.

This is as simple as it gets:

1.       Loosely define learning goals in terms of both communicative task and content.

2.       Is it at the Goldilocks zone for the class in terms of Cognition, Experience, and Language?

3.       What authentic activity can learners perform prepare them for the real life task?

4.       What parameters of the task can be fine-tuned for the higher and lower level students?

5.       Is it feasible? Do we have the necessary scaffolding, props, environment, and time?

6.       Pre-task: What language is necessary for this task?

7.       Fine tune parameters of the task until it is suitable (see fine tuning below)

8.       Prepare the necessary scaffolding, props, environment, and time.

9.       Prepare pre-task and post task activity and or worksheets.

This is a coarse grain flow chart.

 

 

The long reply:

Task based learning formally starts with a Needs Assessment. They are essential with elective learners, small group, ESP, 1 to 1, emigration, and remedial. In Taiwan and much of Asia we have large scale, washback-driven schools using pre-established curricula which often preclude needs analysis. So we employ something closer to Task Supported Language Teaching in which tasks are grafted onto the existing curriculum. Opportunities to implement a full scale TBLT program are rare. ( Click here for brief summaries of my experiences , The case of Lantan, The Case of Meinung JHS)

Here are some things to consider in the choice or design of a task:

1.       Applicability

A.      communicative learning goals

B.      language learning objectives

C.      meta-learning goals (my favorite)

2.       Suitability

A.      number, level, age, and diversity of learners

B.      topics, themes

C.      sequence with other lessons (negligible with TSLT)

D.      i+1: simplexity, flow channel, and the Goldilocks Zone

3.       Feasibility

A.      scalability; fine tuning

B.      time and space allocation

C.      available props and scaffolding

 

Task development is an ongoing process, constantly updating on the fly. Tasks are often revised, refined for next use. This circular model above shows how the goal informs the sub-process of selecting the content and task which informs evaluation which feeds back to inform the goal.

 

 

A task is coarse grain designed or selected for the i+1 level of the majority of the students, usually within the range of the 1st standard deviation, A, in the diagram. Meanwhile we can also consider which fine grain parameters of the task can reduce the challenge for the lower level students, B, and which parameters we can fine tune to increase the challenge for the higher level students, C. (See this entry, FINE TUNE TASK.)

 

 

 

Useful guidelines are presented by Long in his book….

1.       The task itself is the unit of analysis, rather than the grammar or vocabulary.

2.       The task should promote learning by doing.

3.       …provide opportunity to elaborate on the input

4.       …provide rich input

5.       …promote Inductive chunk learning (CEL)

6.       …focus on form

7.       …provide negative feedback such as recasts and corrections in context

8.       …target the I+1 of the learner. “Learnability determines teachability.”

9.       …employ cooperative and  collaborative learning

10.   …offer opportunity to individualize instruction

 

A well-formed task will merge the 3 information streams Cognition, Experience, and Language into a synchronized, laminar, flow. It will reveal the unique interdependencies between the three flows. The result is that the scaffolding, constraints, and affordances in the Experience flow will coordinate with those in both the Cognitive and the Language flows.

The starting point is this: What do we want the students to learn to DO using the language? Buy a ticket, order a meal, negotiate a funeral or wedding, etc.
What context, environment, and props, will best promote this? A mock ticket or window, a mock restaurant menu, a catalog from a funeral or wedding planner, etc
What authentic task can the learner perform which will facilitate the acquisition of that cluster of language, that CEL?
Buy a ticket: Destination, r/t, baggage, seating;
Order a meal: cafeteria, fast food, steak house, 5 star;
Arrange a wedding or funeral: budget, open coffin, in house, etc, number of guests, budget, flowers, meals, band, etc.

Formally designing a TBLT lesson starts with the goal defined in terms of the task. But classroom experience may vary especially if you’re operating within a strict educational curriculum defined in terms of lexicon and syntax such as Taiwan and much of Asia.  If, on the other hand, you start from the language you’re going to immediately cycle to the task. A journey of a thousand li starts with a single step. How much does it matter if it’s the left foot or the right?  

It is this feedback between the task and the language used which enables the teacher to trim the level of complexity of the lesson to the level of the class.

Revisiting the above example this table below shows how the simplexity of the Language is synchronized with the simplexity of the Experience (task setting, props) and with the Cognition load. Synchronization is maintained by the pursuit of the goal. 

 

 

Level

Buy a ticket

 Concepts

 Experience

Language

1

Bus, 1 destination

 Purchase, money, place, time

Give and take cash and ticket

 When? Where How much?

2

Round trip,

+ twice

+do it again

 + twice

3

Train, express, special seating, baggage,

+ choice of seats, priority, baggage

+ more variables, choices

 Which seat, compare? How heavy, how big?

4

Plane, 2 stops, class, meal, wife, seating, etc

+ more choices, appetite, 3rd person

+ more variables, more choices, more anxiety, 3rd person reference

 + food menu, 3rd person conjugations,

5

Handicapped, hotel, car rental, local tours…

+ Constraints, additional times, destinations, activities, preferences.

+ 3rd person and outside the system reference,

 Would you like to also, what time, etc…

6

Report about your bad airline experience

 

 

 

 

In this activity what parameters can you use to decrease the challenge for the B level students? to increase the challenge for the C level students?

All this looks very complex but when you’ve done it a couple times it becomes second nature.

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why me?

Simply Task Based Learning - Simplexity